Comments on: Making the Invisible Visible: It’s All Right to Stare http://www.disabilityandrepresentation.com/2013/06/22/making-the-invisible-visible/ Changing the Cultural Conversation Fri, 12 Jul 2013 02:15:54 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.5.2 By: Katie http://www.disabilityandrepresentation.com/2013/06/22/making-the-invisible-visible/#comment-667287 Katie Fri, 12 Jul 2013 00:29:36 +0000 http://www.disabilityandrepresentation.com/?p=2671#comment-667287 I use a cane off and on too, and I’ve had the same experiences. One of my favorites was when I was leaving brunch at a restaurant, and this little four-year-old girl was just STARING with wide eyes, and called out, “Why you need that?”

You could just see the gears turning in her head: this was something grandma uses, not young women her mother’s age. Why did this grown-up need a cane?

So I told her, sometimes I get REALLY dizzy, and the cane helps me keep from falling down. And she just nodded.

Also, I’m a big fan of the stylish canes. I have a rose-print, a copper marble one, and a black one with tree frogs. I DON’T have any that are “plain.” :)

]]>
By: Red http://www.disabilityandrepresentation.com/2013/06/22/making-the-invisible-visible/#comment-638747 Red Wed, 03 Jul 2013 15:26:17 +0000 http://www.disabilityandrepresentation.com/?p=2671#comment-638747 Thank you for writing this; I felt a wave of recognition at your second paragraph. Living with an undiagnosed sort-of-like-fibromyalgia chronic pain condition for the last seven years, there have been only brief moments, like this one, where I’ve acknowledged to myself the weight that I carry because of this disability being invisible. In a way I’ve lacked the language for it, which is why I so appreciate hearing you voice it.

I am frequently performing, for brief windows of time, the performance of able-bodied. Yet this makes me feel even less understood when I don’t conform to that performance. People don’t know, for example, that when I’m lying down in some public place, it’s not just because I’m lazy/weird, but actually because I physically can’t bear to sit or stand at that time. On the whole I look so damn normal, so I guess the alienation comes in because I look like everyone else but my internal reality of pain/avoiding pain is so constant, that I’m not really living in the same narrative as anyone else whenever movement is involved. That said, it is much easier in my small town where people know me and understand my needs – i.e. at our local organic shop they take out a stool for me to rest on at the counter while they ring up my groceries. Something so tiny that makes a world of difference to my morale.

I guess the stress on this is compounded by my feelings of being judged. I think most people wouldn’t realize how much our society polices physical conformity in terms of how we conduct our bodies – until you have the experience of not being able to conform. Sometimes I receive judgmental comments from acquaintances (and even friends! grr) who wonder why I’m not jumping up to help out with things that are easy for everyone else; sometimes these are voiced and other times I just feel it in the way the person treats me. Other times it’s jokes about how I’m always lying down (whoops! would you say to someone in a wheelchair, ‘haha, you sure are in that wheelchair a lot, that must be nice.’) Other times it’s from people who don’t know what’s going on with me; like being nearly kicked out of a music venue by a very intimidating and hostile bouncer when I was lying down in the aisle, because there was nowhere else to be and I had gotten into too much pain to stand or sit. If I had, say, a wheelchair, I think I would have been treated much more honorably there. Surprisingly, once when I tried using a wheelchair for a day to go to an event that would have entailed too much walking, I felt an odd relief: I was *seen*, people were compassionate, they wanted to help me, open doors, etc. Suddenly the world no longer felt populated by people who don’t understand/aren’t helping, because now they had put me mentally in their “disabled” category. It was oddly liberating. (Still, I was also quite conscious that I was being seen and treated as an “other”.)

Yikes this turned into quite the diatribe!
Mostly I just wanted to thank you for helping me visible-ize my own experience to myself, and to say that I hear you loud and clear. I would love to get myself beyond complaining to a more constructive way of being with all this. But at least getting clear about the dynamics feels like a start.

]]>
By: Disability and Representation» Blog Archive » My Body is Not Public Property: The Disability Version http://www.disabilityandrepresentation.com/2013/06/22/making-the-invisible-visible/#comment-634217 Disability and Representation» Blog Archive » My Body is Not Public Property: The Disability Version Tue, 25 Jun 2013 19:37:42 +0000 http://www.disabilityandrepresentation.com/?p=2671#comment-634217 [...] a few days ago, I wrote a post about what a blessed relief it is have my cane as a visible marker of disability. After living my [...]

]]>
By: Rachel Cohen-Rottenberg http://www.disabilityandrepresentation.com/2013/06/22/making-the-invisible-visible/#comment-633848 Rachel Cohen-Rottenberg Mon, 24 Jun 2013 20:30:45 +0000 http://www.disabilityandrepresentation.com/?p=2671#comment-633848 Hi Nancy,

Like your daughter, I am somewhat prone to staring, which may be one of the reasons that I feel more comfortable with others doing it in my direction. I don’t at all mean to stare, but I end up doing it because I’m trying to understand things about “normal” culture that feel quite “abnormal” to me. Plus, I don’t read body language or subtle facial expressions intuitively, so I often look at people a little longer than “normal” while I’m processing the whole thing. I’ve done that all my life; I will study people’s faces and figure out where they’re at, but it’s not just a passing glance, and it sometimes calls people up short. For instance, a few weeks back my husband and a friend and I were all talking, and I saw a nonverbal facial expression pass between my husband and my friend, so I stood there looking at my friend’s face for a moment while I analyzed it. My friend looked at me and said, “What?” I said, “Oh, sorry, I didn’t mean to stare. I just have to analyze nonverbals and that takes a little while.” As the mom of an autistic kid, she got it and it was no problem.

So at this point, I’m taking staring as an opportunity for contact. It’s amazing to feel oneself objectified by a stare and then step out of it and become a subject for the other person. For me, the problem isn’t so much people staring as the way that some people refuse to stop staring when asked. I have friends who will ask people to stop staring and they don’t. I haven’t had that experience yet, but I can imagine how annoying it is. I understand that some people can’t help but stare, and if there is a good physical or cognitive reason for it and they have a hard time stopping, it wouldn’t bother me. But if they can stop and just plain won’t when asked to — that’s rude.

]]>
By: Nancy http://www.disabilityandrepresentation.com/2013/06/22/making-the-invisible-visible/#comment-633842 Nancy Mon, 24 Jun 2013 17:27:24 +0000 http://www.disabilityandrepresentation.com/?p=2671#comment-633842 I agree. It is okay to stare. Most staring is really just about curiosity not judgement or criticism. My daughter (who has autism) stares A LOT. I think staring may be part of the way to acceptance. First there has to be some curiosity, some questions answered, some observation, then some understanding and then acceptance. To expect others to accept, but don’t look too much seems unreasonable.

]]>
By: Rachel Cohen-Rottenberg http://www.disabilityandrepresentation.com/2013/06/22/making-the-invisible-visible/#comment-633631 Rachel Cohen-Rottenberg Mon, 24 Jun 2013 01:16:36 +0000 http://www.disabilityandrepresentation.com/?p=2671#comment-633631 E, I so much relate to what you’re saying about feeling much more accepted with a visible marker of disability. I think it has to do with the phenomenon that you describe so well on your blog — the way that, because we have invisible disabilities, people first see us as normal, then see us as different, and then decide we’re too different to deal with. The visible marker in some way relaxes me about being different because it’s letting people know up front what to expect, and they can avoid me up front or not. Whether they see me as “You’re different and interesting” or “You’re different and Other,” it’s a much more straightforward interaction. Either way, I am much freer to be myself.

That’s produced a certain comfort about being myself that is quite different from my usual struggle about how to present myself, and I think that has a lot to do with the ease of some of these interactions. I’m not caught in the weird ambiguity of “I’m disabled, but it’s invisible, until you start talking to me for awhile, in which case you notice something different, and then you start noticing that I’m *really* different, and then you decide that I’ve somehow defrauded you because my disbility is invisible and you never would have started the interaction in the first place if you’d known.” There is no ambiguity, no sense of “What? I thought you were normal!” followed by pulling away. If people are going to pull away, they avoid me up front, which I much, much prefer to stepping into situations in which I’m waiting for the other shoe to drop.

]]>
By: Rachel Cohen-Rottenberg http://www.disabilityandrepresentation.com/2013/06/22/making-the-invisible-visible/#comment-633630 Rachel Cohen-Rottenberg Mon, 24 Jun 2013 01:07:03 +0000 http://www.disabilityandrepresentation.com/?p=2671#comment-633630 Jenni, I read about a similar type of situation in Tobin Siebers’ Disability Theory, in which he talks about a Deaf man who was hit on the shoulder and hassled by a guard at the Metropolitan Museum of Art for not responding the first time to a request to not sit on the floor. He said that in order to signal that he is Deaf, he was considering getting a red hearing aid. He didn’t need it to hear; he needed it to signal that he *couldn’t* hear.

I have sometimes thought about getting a hearing aid to signal that I have an audiological condition. A hearing aid would actually be the last thing I need — my hearing is almost completely unfiltered and doesn’t need to be amplified — but it would let people know “hearing problem here.” It’s felt somewhat appropriative to do that — after all, I’m not HoH — but I’m rethinking that now. I *do* have a hearing problem, and there is no other marker for it. And certainly, if I used a hearing aid, I would turn it all the way down — or off.

]]>
By: Rachel Cohen-Rottenberg http://www.disabilityandrepresentation.com/2013/06/22/making-the-invisible-visible/#comment-633629 Rachel Cohen-Rottenberg Mon, 24 Jun 2013 00:59:01 +0000 http://www.disabilityandrepresentation.com/?p=2671#comment-633629 Casey, I was just thinking today that there is a kind of hierarchy of mobility aids. Most people are probably more comfortable with a person using a cane than a person using a wheelchair — partly because more people know someone who uses a cane (and so it feels more familiar), and partly because people who use a cane are still ambulating on two feet, which is highly prized.

]]>
By: Rachel Cohen-Rottenberg http://www.disabilityandrepresentation.com/2013/06/22/making-the-invisible-visible/#comment-633628 Rachel Cohen-Rottenberg Mon, 24 Jun 2013 00:56:54 +0000 http://www.disabilityandrepresentation.com/?p=2671#comment-633628 Alana, it seems that people need that visual signal, don’t they? It’s as though they need a little bit of advance warning that something different is going on. I also wonder whether the visible indicator acts as a kind of proof-test to other people that we actually are disabled; words often don’t seem to have the same impact. I sometimes think that using a mobility aid is so potentially stigmatizing that the average person might be thinking, “That person wouldn’t be using that cane if it weren’t really necessary.”

]]>
By: E (The Third Glance) http://www.disabilityandrepresentation.com/2013/06/22/making-the-invisible-visible/#comment-633451 E (The Third Glance) Sun, 23 Jun 2013 16:57:17 +0000 http://www.disabilityandrepresentation.com/?p=2671#comment-633451 Thank you for writing this, Rachel. I’ve noticed the same phenomenon many times. My only disability (at the moment) is autism, and all the sensory processing, klutziness, etc. that goes along with it. But that means I have spent cumulative more than a full year on crutches in my life at this point, from various breaks and sprains, usually acquired when walking off of curbs or tripping over my own feet. And I notice that people’s perceptions of my “other” change when something is visible. Especially a temporary visible disability masks my autism, and people treat me with respect and as a whole person in ways they don’t when I have two good feet. And it’s very strange. I used to have an obsession with visible disabilities, just for that reason. Because if I had a visible disability, people would treat me better. It’s strange in a way, but I just wanted to say how much this post resonated with me.

]]>